Security or Compliance?

There is a debate among security professionals as to whether a strong compliance or strong security program best protects the enterprise.  Arguments along the lines of compliance is “just satisfying a checklist” and “security is not compliance” are offered.  Obviously compliance requirements must be satisfied and often compliance programs help justify “security” programs and budgets.  But what is the relationship?

I believe the following simple relationship captures the connection between compliance and security:

Security = Compliance + Continuous Improvement

Compliance establishes a baseline for the security program.  This baseline may be regulated or legislated or be an organizational requirement.  However, often compliance is checked only annually and by individuals who may not be aware of the risks that are present in a specific organization.  The security program has a broader mandate, namely to protect the intellectual capital in the enterprise.

A security continuous improvement program will “fill in” the gaps between annual audits.  It can be used to reduce costs of audits and compliance.  It can be used to adjust to changing threats and business conditions.  This type of continuous improvement program is “built in” to the security program and is not just another check box to be filled in under as part of the annual audit.  A successful Continuous Improvement program is built on strong metrics that are reported weekly and provided to all stakeholders in the security program.

Security and compliance are both essential parts of protecting information and by implementing continuous improvement, organizations can realize the benefits of both.

Frederick Scholl

Frederick Scholl is an accomplished Global Senior Information Security Risk Manager. Dr. Scholl earned a BS and Ph.D. in Electrical Engineering from Cornell University. In 1991, Fred founded Monarch Information Networks, LLC to enable forward-thinking organizations to protect their information. Previously, he co-founded Codenoll Technology Corporation (NASDAQ: CODN). He chaired the IEEE committee that wrote the first standard for Ethernet communication over fiber optic links, now used world-wide.

Book an Appointment for Cybersecurity Issues

Request an appointment with Dr. Fred Scholl. We will discuss any cybersecurity issues you have.

More Good Reading

Cybersecurity Thrives in An Organizational Context

The First National Cybersecurity Summit

New Privacy Laws Require Security Professionals Up Their Game

Cybersecurity Workforce Development: Real or Imagined Problem?

Antidote for Fake Everything

Information Security Risks, Gray Rhinos and Black Swans

Managing Information Security On a Limited Budget

Building a Security Start-Up

Cybersecurity Risk Management for Directors

My Reading List for Security Start-Ups

Should Your CIO Learn to Code?

How IT Leaders Can Keep a Seat at the Table

Equifax points out—again—the need for speed in security management

Anatomy of a Security Breach

The Smartest Information Security Companies

Book Review: Play Bigger

Long Term Beneficiaries of WannaCry

RISK: A NEW MOVIE ABOUT JULIAN ASSANGE

TRADE SECRET THEFT CONTINUES UNABATED

TENNESSEE LEGISLATORS MUDDY WATERS AROUND PRIVACY BREACH NOTIFICATION REQUIREMENTS

LEADERSHIP CHECKLIST FOR SECURITY PROFESSIONALS

SIEM VENDORS HAVE IT ALL BACKWARDS

THE SECRET TO GROWING YOUR SECURITY STARTUP

CLOUD JOBS PEAKING?

The Spy Who Couldn’t Spell

IS THERE A CYBERSECURITY PROFESSIONALS SHORTAGE?

No Blue Pill for Cybersecurity Failures

Presidential Cybersecurity Commission Makes Some Good Suggestions

Understanding Intelligence

Align Your Security Program With the Business

Don’t fall victim to BEC

Enterprise Risk Management and Information Security

Evidence Based Risk Assessment: Lessons Learned from the Y-12 Breach

First Conviction for Illegally Distributing Android Apps

Locking Up the Ivory Tower

Cloud Vulnerabilities

More Security Lessons Learned from the Y-12 Breach

Security or Compliance?

Home Disaster Recovery Planning

Cloud Computing: Trust but Verify

Background Checks May Not Be Enough

PERFECT SECURITY STORM FOR LAW FIRMS?

How Not To Be a Cyber Janitor

SECURITY MEMO: IT CAN’T HAPPEN HERE, CAN IT?

Don’t Forget Cloud Availability

Compliance v. Security

GAO Report on Information Security in Federal Government

Lean Security

Mitigate Your Social Engineering Vulnerabilities

HIPAA Security. Are We Making Progress?

Brand Your Security Program

PDCA is Dead

LEARNING FROM PAST MISTAKES

How Better Security Can Create Shared Value

C’est La Vie, You Never Can Tell: Lessons Learned from the HBGary Hack

DDOS Tutorial

The future of information technology

Data Governance Anyone?

Learning from the oil spill disaster

Down the Rabbit-Hole…Again?

Ideas on Risk Management